Skip to main content

For Once, Amazon Loses a Popularity Contest

Personally, I was against the deal, but I had mixed feelings, even afterward. For some portions of our economy Amazon coming might have been good news, e.g., real estate, technology, and support industries. For others, and for infrastructure services in NYC, my sense was that it would have been a strain and a drain, taxing our resources and us subsidizing it with tax breaks, leading to higher costs for local inhabitants. My later thoughts had to do with evening out our economy, so heavily reliant on finance.

For myself, I've worked in technology for 30 years, mostly in finance but lately medical. I live in Manhattan, in one of the more densely tech-inhabited areas, and Amazon would have likely been good for me personally, although that is debatable. A large number of tech job, and with Amazon's higher pay, might have both made tech jobs more competitive while also making it more lucrative. Even then, Amazon has reached out to me several times about working for them, but then again, I am always getting emails and call about roles, many of it the equivalent of spam.

In the end, on one hand, I'm glad Amazon was rebuffed because of its potential harm to NYC, but then again, I likely would have liked to see the gleaming towers and growth that it would have brought. Regardless, NYC will still grow, will still be highly unequal, and technology will still take over more jobs, but maybe not so quickly as if Amazon been able to stay.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/14/business/amazon-new-york-city.html?comments#permid=30635150

@citizennotconsumer - I think you underestimate how much this hurts Amazon. Publicly, Amazon can decry the local politics to the media, but internally, they will have to blame themselves for the ignorance and bad decision-making that went ahead with the plan. A high-level decision should have been smarter, should have taken into account the potential pushback, should have done better PR. It is a failure of decision-making at a high-level within Amazon...

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/14/business/amazon-new-york-city.html?comments#permid=30634885:30635376




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why Amazon Is Caught in an Unexpected Brawl in New York

#1 I was surprised that less affluent groups and minorities were for Amazon coming to NYC, although I was aware that locals in my area would be in favor. I live in Murray Hill, and it has a large number of software developers, in number and percentage, in Manhattan, and many - most? - people in our zip code earn in the six figures. I've worked as a software developer for over 15 years, and have occasionally been contacted by Amazon for my skills, although I would not put too much on this as I am always being contacted by recruiters, much of worthless. Although I am likely to benefit from Amazon coming to NYC, I am not a fan of the deal in its current incarnation. It takes too much money from our coffers, circumvents city governance, will place a large burden on existing resources, and will drive up costs for many New York residents. It seems the biggest boosters would be the real estate industry, along with anyone that might be able to profit from selling to the behemoth... h...
Post a Comment
Read more

Former Elections

In a post on another of my sites, a prediction of the 2004 election , I reprinted an email I sent to Brian Lehrer's show of my election prediction. I was wrong in multiple ways, not only because I was overly optimistic, hoping that American's would reject the Republican party, but also because I thought the turn away would be based on mass awareness of economic and social injustice. Even if I had been correct, the turning away I predicted would have likely been based on more concrete and less lofty reasons, since it seems that the Republicans' fall from grace seems more based on their inability to win a war, not the humanitarian crisis of the war itself.
Post a Comment
Read more

Raison d'Etre (Reason for Being)

I recently picked up Philip Tetlock's Expert Political Judgment , an insightful analysis of expert opinion. Although there are many factors that might distinguish experts in the ability to predict outcomes, liberal versus conservative, intellectual depth and education, source material, etc., Tetlock found that the best predictor of forecasting accuracy was thinking like a fox, as opposed to the hedgehog, ala Isaiah Singer's essay. Fox thinking is nuanced and composed of many different themes, often conflicting, while hedgehogs tend to believe in one big, overarching idea. This site, and my expected use, is to document my own failures and successes in predicting political and economic futures. The title, Elephant's Memory, alludes to the fox-like tendency, maybe even need, to remember one's own flawed predictions and adjust future reasoning accordingly.
Post a Comment
Read more